SBN 182586 PDF Writ of Administrative Mandamus a clear, present and ministerial duty on the part of the respondent, and. Accordingly, petiti Spector v City of Los Angeles SOURCEWISE, Case No. Deputy Clerk: Kristi Temple Dept: SB Dept 4 rmedonald@carlsonnicholas.com In that case, applicants who had been denied a permit for a planned unit shopping center development sought a writ of mandate. Chapter 2. Writ Of Mandate :: California Code of Civil Procedure Statutory writs differ from common law writs primarily concerning the deadlines in which to file the writ petition. Pasadena, CA 91101 at 259. Petition for writ of mandate, Rita Miller, Judge. The alternative writ triggers further briefing (a return and reply) as well as an oral hearing. B, F, G.) PDF ANAHEIM CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE GREGG M. AUDET (SBN 158682) - Voice of OC 105365) State of California MATTHEW BOERMEESTER,, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. . If the Court of Appeal grants the petition, the alternative writ or order to show cause will be discharged and a peremptory writ issued. 4 One common mistake is burying this showing in the substance of their legal arguments. $300.00. Case No. App., Fourth Dist., Local Rule 1(a).) Your subscription was successfully upgraded. 30-2019-01107063-cu-np-cjc _____ preliminary opposition to petition for writs of mandamus, prohibition, and review She has been AV-rated by Martindale-Hubbell. 6 Petitioner Nowicki challenges the legal decision made by the Contra Costa County Employees Retirement Association Board ("CCCERA"), following a hearing held Adding your team is easy in the "Manage Company Users" tab. (Id.) California Civil Writ Practice | Legal Resources | CEB | CEB 8 SU, 1 Ernest J. Franceschi, Jr. (SBN 112893) Accordingly, the Court should either set the case down for plenary review, or grant the petition outright and send the case back for further proceedings. Opposition. Get free summaries of new opinions delivered to your inbox! NXmU1.lO~&HUqqf`B|2Yy2pWE|3 Q{\'$K 8Bx kggbl]Pw 5r6S+*z>"Ko!uH*9gk}-p )nMEso>b*QD3u#02wim-}X?!X-2 NO 28 JUDGE HON. As simple as the motion to quash hearing is, the judges make a surprising number of mistakes in ruling upon it. Petition for writ of mandate granted. If you filed a Motion to Quash - California Tenant Law Proc. Additionally, the cover should contain the following information: the nature of the ruling, proceeding, or act to be stayed and the date by which the stay is requested. Confusing, because "petition for writ of mandate" describes two completely different proceedings: Explanation: 2 16130 Ventura Blvd., Suite 600 ), SD em DH Bw HN The Court of Appeal has original jurisdiction over a writ petition. nonprofit corporation; SONJA TRAUSS; and ) Also, it generally must be special in the sense that it is over and above the interest held in common by the public at large. Discretion is the power conferred on public functionaries to act officially according to the dictates of their own judgment. (AIDS Healthcare Foundation v. Los Angeles County Dep't of Pub. Rules of Court, rule 8.112.) 4 Email: ejf@franceschilaw.com 161 - Reply to Opposition to Petition for Writ of Mandate. Produced by 'The Ezra Klein Show'. Colusa, CA 95932 5/6/2020 PDF PETITION FOR WRIT BOOKLET - occourts.org 238514101 Howard Street, Suite 400 San Francisco, California 94105-6125 Telephone: (415) 655.8100 ~ Facsimile: (415) 655.8099Email: szutler@bwslaw.com ) try clicking the minimize button instead. FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES Tentative Ruling: As amended through March 24, 2023 Rule 8.487 - Opposition and amicus curiae briefs (a) Preliminary opposition (1) Within 10 days after the petition is filed, the respondent or any real party in interest, separately or jointly, may serve and file a preliminary opposition. As of March 2020, the California Supreme Court implemented mandatory electronic filing (for all but a narrow category of pro per individuals and those who have been excused from the requirements under local rules) through its platform TrueFiling.com. (Code Civ. 2023 10 This sample petition for release of mechanics lien for California is filed pursuant to Civil Code sections 8480, et seq. On July 13, 2018, Plaintiff filed an administrative appeal, requesting $65 as compensation for his allegedly missing property. cause why a peremptory writ should not issue as requested in the petition for writ of mandate, and afforded the parties the opportunity for further briefing and oral argument.1 1 We granted the application of Bet Tzedek, California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation, Center For Workers' Rights, Centro Legal De La Raza, Legal Aid At Work, Facsimile: (626) 356-4801 ), Denial of motion to quash service of process (Code Civ. (Pet., p. 1, and Exs. Disclaimer: These codes may not be the most recent version. (Lewis v. Sup.Ct. As explained below, none of these contentions has merit. ) 7 Therefore, if the petitioner has an adequate remedy in the form of an ordinary cause of action a writ of mandate must be denied. (Agosto V. Board of Trustees of the Grossmont-Cuyamaca Community College District (2010) 189 Cal.App.4th 330, 345. (Green) (1999) 19 Cal.4th 1232, 1260, fn. (Subd (c) adopted effective January 1, 2014.). Rules of Court, rule 8.116(c). (Cal. OPPOSITION TO MOTIONS FOR WRIT OF MANDATE A N, A N, L A, R UUD & R O O N W 5 E S E, S 700 L A J A, C 7-7 T E:) 485-6 1 I. [17], As appeals from the outcome of writ petitions in the superior court. 4 review of the august 2, 20__ order denying defendants' motion for summary judgment entered by the superior court of california, county of redwood, case no. On July 19, 2019, Clyde Davis (Plaintiff) filed a lawsuit stylized as a Petition for Writ of Mandate (Code of Civil Proc., 1085, 1086 et seq. 1000 E. G. OLDSTEIN. Petitioners request that the court take the Petition and Verified Answer under submission without further briefing or presentation of evidence, decide the matter on the pleadings, and decide the Petition on the pleadings a ..owed in civil actions are complaints, demurrers, answers, and cross-complaints. The writ panel may deny the writ petition without opposition, or the writ panel may issue an order denying the writ after . 5 PDF Law Library for San Bernardino County 430.10(e).) (2) An opposition must contain a memorandum and a statement of any material fact not included in the petition. 126525) A court seldom issues a peremptory writ in the first instance without proceeding first with an alternative writ and additional briefing. Only a few specific orders besides final judgments are subject to appeal in California. Therefore, it is a good practice to call the clerks office to notify the clerk if you plan to oppose a stay request, because the Court of Appeal may issue a stay without waiting for a response. April 28, 2023 at 7:29 a.m. EDT. App., Second Dist., Local Rule 6. Proc., 923 [empowering court to keep the status quo through stay or other orders unrelated to merits of the action]). It is ordered that the peremptory writ of mandate issue as prayed. Preliminary Opposition to Petition for Writ of Mandate, Prohibition Rules of Court, rules 8.116(a), 8.486(a)(7)(B).) 2 (530) 513-8050 Usually, quasi-legislative acts are reviewed by ordinary mandate and quasi-judicial acts are reviewed by administrative mandate. (McGill v. Regents of the Univ. Although the statute does not expressly forbid the issuance of the writ if another adequate remedy exists, it has long been established as a general rule that the writ will not be issued if another such remedy was available to the petitioner. (Phelan v. Super. 8 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 1085 & 1094.5; Bunnett v. Regents of University of California (1995) 35 Cal. PDF 2nd Civil No. B291170 LASC No. BC517444 - KCT Calper- KCT Legal (a) (1) Any party to an action in which it is alleged that two or more parties are joint tortfeasors or co-obligors on a contract debt shall be entitled to a hearing on the issue of the good faith of a settlement entered into by the plaintiff or other claimant and one or more alleged tortfeasors or co-obligors, upon giving notice in the manner Proc., 431.30; Mechling v. Asbestos Defendants (2018) 29 Cal.App.5th 1241, 1248. hb```*f A !Fw'2^ `@G gTJTN2MoT fBa`28H10v40Et04t00w40v0IFrGKDn '30\c q#+ZFWfVeeLc`j$ J2 California Tenant Law. In any event, within 10 days after the petition for writ of mandate/prohibition/certiorari is filed, the respondent or any real party in interest may (separately or jointly) file and serve a preliminary opposition. Proc. DATE/TIME October 18, 2019, 10:00 a.m. DEPT. ) %PDF-1.6 % Unlike the federal court system, where interlocutory appeals may be taken on a permissive basis and mandamus are usually used to contest recusal decisions, the writ of mandate in California is not restricted to purely ministerial tasks, but can be used to correct any legal error by the trial court. Proc. [35] Proceedings subject to review by administrative mandate usually occur before state government agencies, such as the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board, the State Hearings Division of the Department of Social Services and the various divisions of the Department of Industrial Relations. provides a party may make a return to a petition for writ of mandate by demurrer, verified answer, or both. Judge Mary Strobel Statutory writs include (but are not limited to) the following: Grant or denial of motion to disqualify judge (Code Civ. [A] writ of mandate may not be issued where the petitioner's rights are otherwise adequately protected. (Code of Civ. Where the case involves the interpretation of a statute, [the reviewing appellate court] engage[s] in de novo review of the trial court's determination to issue the writ of mandate. PRELIMINARY OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDATE, PROHIBITION, AND/OR OTHER APPROPRIATE RELIEF David E. Mastagni, Bar No. (Cal. 1085 is used to review adjudicatory actions or decisions when the agency was not required to hold an evidentiary hearing. Where the appellate division grants a writ of mandate directed to the superior court, the superior court is an inferior tribunal for purposes of this chapter. California Code of Civil Procedure 877.6 (2019) - Justia Law ), In either case, the essential underpinning of the challenge is the invalidity of the administrative action. ), A ruling in a Public Records Act case (Gov. 3 JUSTIN MI (Ex. v. State Personnel Bd. PDF Mandate (aka "Mandamus %%EOF App. The terms mandamus and mandate are synonymous. PDF United States Court of Appeals for The Ninth Circuit CA Court of Appeal Opinions and Cases | FindLaw Get a Demo. April 28, 2023. (Pet., p. 1, and Exs. If you wish to keep the information in your envelope between pages, Writ of Mandate; Opposition v. Return - Legal Answers - Avvo Case No. [G]eneral allegations, without reference to any facts, are not sufficient to sustain [the] burden of showing that [an alternative] remedy would be inadequate. (Phelan v. Super. Opposition To Petition For Writ Of Mandate (21STCP03149) ROB BONTA Attorney General of California . (Cal. The nature of the administrative action or decision to be reviewed determines the applicable type of mandate. 5, Form APP-150-INFO, California Judicial Council, pg. (Id. vs. ) fPROPOSED] WRIT OF MANDATE 301 E. Colorado Blvd., Suite 320 On July 19, 2019, Clyde Davis (Plaintiff) filed a lawsuit stylized as a Petition for Writ of Mandate (Code of Civil Proc., 1085, 1086 et seq. Ct. (Great American Ins. 327673 [3] Unlike the federal court system, where interlocutory appeals may be taken on a permissive basis and mandamus are usually used to contest recusal decisions, the writ of mandate in California is not restricted to purely ministerial tasks, but can be used to correct any legal error by the trial court. She has been repeatedly voted as one of the Super Lawyers Rising Stars in Appellate Law (Southern California). 3 NEO KHUU (SBN 312540) by the author. Proc., 418.10, subd. endstream endobj 173 0 obj <. In broad strokes, the Court of Appeal may summarily deny the writ petition, may issue an alternative writ, may issue a suggestive Palma notice, or may grant the petition. Such notices alert the parties that the appellate court is strongly considering issuing a peremptory writ granting the requested relief, provides a brief legal discussion indicating the trial court erred, and, further indicates that if the trial court reverses its order, the writ petition would be summarily denied as moot. : 21STCP02987 Proc., 1086 [to correct abuse of discretion or enforce a nondiscretionary duty]), writs of prohibition (Code Civ. Services. . SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA County of Sacramento 720 Ninth Street ~ Room 102 Sacramento, CA 95814-1380 (916) 874-5522 Website www.saccourt.com GUIDE TO THE PROCEDURES FOR PROSECUTING PETITIONS FOR PREROGATIVE WRITS (as specified in Local Rule 2.26(E)) Filing a Writ Petition: Serving a Writ Petition: Last. Proc., 1088, 1105. Proc. . [1][2] In California, certain writs are used by the superior courts, courts of appeal and the Supreme Court to command lower bodies, including both courts and administrative agencies, to do or not to do certain things. For most rulings, counsel has an option to bring a writ or to see how the case proceeds and, if necessary, challenge the adverse ruling on appeal from the final judgment. Petitioner, Warden, Lt. Arebelo Fox Yard Lieutenant, Sgt. Richard A. McDonald (State Bar No. Your subscription was successfully upgraded. 204244 Taylor Davies-Mahaffey, Bar No. COUNTY OF SANTA BARBARA San Francisco, California 94102-4682 Telephone: (415) 554-4675 Facsimile: (415) 554-4699 E-Mail: wayne.snodgrass@sfcityatty.org . Despite the statistical deterrent for writ success, under appropriate circumstances, writ relief may be the only way to prevent your client from suffering a significant miscarriage of justice. December 21, 2016. IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 9 Janet is the owner and principal of Gusdorff Law, P.C., in Westlake Village, CA. verified petition for writ of mandate and damages - 1 1 2 3 4 email: 5 c 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 ) 20 ) 21 22 ) 23 24 b 25 (" 26 27 Sign up for our free summaries and get the latest delivered directly to you. Proc. (4) If the return is by demurrer alone and the demurrer is not sustained, the court may issue the peremptory writ without granting leave to answer. AIDS HEALTHCARE FOUNDATION VS CITY OF LOS ANGELES, ET AL. Practices & Procedures - 2DCA - California 1085. Any preliminary opposition, return, or opposition must comply with rule 8.931(c). Read Read Cited Authorities Cited Authorities 14. PDF DENNIS J. HERRERA, State Bar #139669 State Bar - LCCRSF ), The appropriate type of mandate is determined by the nature of the administrative action or decision under review. (Beach & Bluff Conservancy v. City of Solana Beach (2018) 28 Cal.App.5th 244, 258.) 2 22 will be able to access it on trellis. ), To obtain writ review, a petitioner must show not only the presence of a ministerial duty, but that his or her remedy in the ordinary course of law is inadequate or that petitioner would suffer irreparable injury were the writ not granted. (Interinsurance Exchange of Automobile Club v. Super. Advocate Magazine are Copyright 2023 by Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles. #231 ) 1 James Diskint (SBN 329114) Moua v. Hmong Cultural New Year Celebration, Inc. MARSHA SPECTOR VS CITY OF LOS ANGELES, ET AL. - 4th Dist. Facsimile: (213) 797-7488 #325201) ), Grant or denial of motion for summary adjudication or denial of motion for summary judgment (Code Civ. The petitioner must not have any other adequate remedy at law; 2. VS KIM JOHNSON, DIRECTOR, CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF SOCIA. For instance, the petitioner must successfully demonstrate to the Court of Appeal that he/she/it satisfies the following requirements: 1. Mandate will not issue to compel action unless it is shown the duty to do the thing asked for is plain and unmixed with discretionary power or the exercise of judgment. (Unnamed Physician v. Board of Trustees of Saint Agnes Medical Center (2001) 93 Cal.App.4th 607, 618. 3 Attorney for Petitioner, Rafael Lozano 19STCP04247 [4] Despite the name, however, ordinary mandate encompasses a wider variety of administrative appeals than administrative mandate does, and an administrative mandate petition may allege ordinary mandate as another cause of action. The court may issue an alternative writ, an order to show cause or a peremptory writ. COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA EXEMPT FROM FILING FEES Proc. 5 Telephone: (213) 269-6258 445 South Figueroa Street, Suite 3100 Los Angeles, California 90071 (213) 699-1355 Telephone albert@lalitigators.com riddick@lalitigators.com JAMES BAINBRIDGE, ESQ. ), The rates for successfully obtaining writ relief are abysmal. Jeremy .Pilaar@cco.sccgov.org SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA Your content views addon has successfully been added. Language links are at the top of the page across from the title. Petitioner has stated facts sufcient to constitute a val ..ormance of an act which the law specically enjoins, as a duty resulting from an ofce, trust, or station, Under this section, mandate will lie to compel performance of a clear, present, and usually ministerial duty in cases where a petitioner has a clear, present and benecial right to performance of that duty. Const. Each statute which specifically allows a writ to be filed comes with a specific statute of limitations, usually 20 days or less. A writ of mandate may be issued by any court to any inferior tribunal, corporation, board, or person, to compel the performance of an act which the law specially enjoins, as a duty resulting from an office, trust, or station, or to compel the admission of a party to the use and enjoyment of a right or office to which the party is entitled, and from which the party is unlawfully precluded by that inferior tribunal, corporation, board, or person. _____ appeal from the superior court for the county of orange hon. DATE/TIME July 20, 2018, 11:00 a.m. DEPT. endstream Judicial Officer: Donna D Geck ) Dept. Joel R. Wohlfeil Date: November 18, 2020 Time: 1:30 pm PDF ROB BONTA Attorney General of California BENJAMIN B An answer must contain whatever denials that are necessary to controvert the material allegations of the complaint. v. Ca. . 5 (Ct. (Gong v. City of Fremont (1967) 250 Cal.App.2d 568, 573; Code Civ. Note that the court proceeds with respect to related writ cases under rule 3.300(h)(1) of the California Rules of Court (CRC) as follows: The judges assigned to civil writ cases listed in a Notice Of Related Case Oroville, CA 95965 A separately filed request for a temporary stay must also be served on the respondent. Rules of Court, rule 8.490(b)(2)(A). 1702 S. Robertson Blvd. A brief in opposition to the petition for a writ of certiorari may be filed by the respondent in any case, but is not mandatory except in a capital case, see Rule 14.1 (a) or when ordered by the Court. Warden, Lt. Arebelo Fox Yard Lieutenant, Sgt. The Demurrers to the Complaint of Defendants City of Los Angeles and Los Angeles City Council, and Real Parties in Interest CH Palladium, LLC, CH Palladium Holdings, LLC, 5929 Sunset (Hollywood), LLC, CRE-HAR Crossroads SPV, LLC and 6400 Sunset LLC are SUSTAINED without leave to amend. La Jolla, California 92037-1477 Telephone: (858) 485-9526 Fax: (858) 485-9412 Attorneys for Respondent . (137027) JASON RIDDICK, ESQ. "A writ of (ordinary) mandate may be issued by any court to any inferior tribunal, corporation, board, or person, to compel the performance of an act which the law specially enjoins, as a duty resulting from an office, trust, or station, or to compel the admission of a party to the use and enjoyment of a right or office to which the party is 1 David E. Rosen (State Bar No. If writs confuse you, you are in good company. ..The tentative ruling shall become the final ruling of the Court unless a party wishing to be heard so advises the clerk of this Department no later than 4:00 p.m. on the court day preceding the hearing, and further advises the clerk that such party has notified the other side of its intention to appear. App. is$"N4s]|FPriU%j(SX CITY OF SAN MARINO, a general law cit, ost KN MW The second prong of the beneficial interest test is whether the interest the plaintiff seeks to advance is within the zone of interests to be protected or regulated by the legal duty asserted. (Waste Management of Alameda County, Inc. v. County of Alameda (2000) 79 Cal.App.4th 1223, 1233-1234. Non-Criminal: Minute Order - Writ of Mandate, Johnny Mirzapour vs Bureau of Automotive Repair, ARMAHN PARRISH, ET AL. 11, Other Civil Petition (General Jurisdiction), 1 BRUCE S. ALPERT (SBN 075684) EXEMPT FROM FILING FEES Rules of Court, rule 8.112.). H2$Xq 1094.5 and is a Writ issued for purpose of inquiring into validity of final administrative order or decision made in proceedings requiring a hearing. (Code Civ. Telephone: (626) 356-4801 Coastal Com. Bureau of Automotive R, 1 DECLARATION OF GREG W. CHAMBERS IN SUPPORT OF REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN OPPOSITION TO FIRST AMENDED VERIFIED PETITION FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, WRIT OF MANDATE AND ATTORNEYS FEES (TRANSACTION ID # 62155482) FILED BY RESPONDENT MEDICAL BOARD OF CALIFORNIA June 19, 2018. COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES each type of writ: see California Code of Civil Procedure sections 1084-1097 about writs of mandate, sections 1102-1105 about writs of prohibition, and sections 1067-1077 about writs of review. Petitioner,) [PREFESED] WRIT OF MANDATE ), A ruling on the disqualification of a judge (Code Civ. ), There are two prongs to the test for the beneficial interest required to pursue an action in mandamus. 2. The writ petition does not automatically stay the proceedings in the trial court or stay enforcement of a judgment or order. California as the proper venue for any litigation. A stay request to the Court of Appeal requires indicating whether or not a stay was first requested in the lower court, and if not, why. Beyond that window, it becomes increasingly difficult to show a likelihood of imminent and irreparable harm. Dist. 1. 4 (Bayley v. Regents of the University of California (1997) 58 Cal. 401 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 850 On July 13, 2018, Plaintiff filed an administrative appeal, requesting $65 as compensation for his allegedly missing property. Judicial Officer: Donna D Geck Young Tockgo, et al., v. Hanin Federal Credit Union, et al. Related Case: Sample California petition for release of mechanics lien - SlideShare James C. Chalfant Writ of Mandate to an Appellate Court. [11], The vast majority of appellate writs are summarily denied without explanation, as, with very few exceptions, they are not a 'cause' which requires an appellate court to make a 'decision in writing with reasons stated', as required by the California Constitution. Posted on Jun 26, 2014. the petitioner has a clear and beneficial right to performance. 1 BRUCE S. ALPERT (SBN 075684) EXEMPT FROM FILING FEES Butte County Counsel Pursuant to Government 2 BRAD STEPHENS (SBN 212246) Code Section 6103 Assistant County Counsel 3 25 County Center Drive, Suite 210 Oroville, CA 95965 4 (530) 538-7621. (B) Immediately request a transcript of the relevant proceedings, which is usually a required part of the record. Ct. (1950) 35 Cal.2d 363, 366.) 2 (d). Rules of Court, rule 8.112(c).). Deputy Sheriff: Marco Diaz Your content views addon has successfully been added. The difference between a writ of mandate and a writ of prohibition. Adding your team is easy in the "Manage Company Users" tab. 4.) Within 10 days thereafter, the petitioner may file and serve a reply. 543, 537 P.2d 375, addressed a similar issue. Once more than 90 days have passed since the mechanics lien was recorded and the lien claimant has failed to file an action to . vs Writ of Mandate 28 [16], Certain writs are prescribed by statute. Following the briefing and argument, the court issues a written opinion. COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA RICHARD K. SUEYOSHI CLERK E. GONZALEZ (Cal. (c). On March 7, 2013, the Court of Appeal issued its opinion reversing the judgment (order granting petition for a writ of administrative mandate) in favor of Monarch and remanding with directions to deny the petition. 9 In a writ of mandate proceeding, the petition is in the nature of a complaint. PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDATE San Diego County Superior Court Case No. There are two essential requirements to the issuance of an ordinary writ of mandate: (California Assn for Health Services at Home v. Department of Health Services (2007) 148 Cal.App.4th 696, 704. Section 108, Government Officials Conflicts and Self-Dealing, Government Influence (Political Reform Act). Ruling on Petition for Writ of Mandate in Doe v. Carry (5 CT 893-906) 4 To avoid the obvious implication that nearly all California government agency decisions were now entirely immune from judicial review, the court held in 1939 that the writ of mandate could be used instead for that purpose.[34]. Additional circumstances that may increase the likelihood of writ relief include opportunities for the appellate court to: resolve conflicts amongst trial courts in the application of a law; correct a ruling or order that is both clearly erroneous and causes petitioner substantial prejudice; to correct a ruling or order that substantially deprives a party of its opportunity to plead or present a substantial portion of the claim; to protect a potential violation of privilege; to address newly enacted legislation; or to address a matter of widespread interest. (See Anderson v. PDF WKH&$ VW'LVWULFW&RXUWRI$SSHDO - Citizen PDF In the Court of Appeal of The State of California Third Appellate Jay M. Bloom Victor Manuel Torres CA State Bar No.
Suleika Jaouad Seamus Mckiernan, Ffxiv Stay At Papalymo Side Or Leave, Articles O